I made a present! A very cheesy homemade one. I basically finger painted an empty (of course) tissue box to make it look like a cricket pitch and made some stick people and said it's a cricket game. I didn't explain the rules though... But hey, he got a (cruddy) present, I got finger painting!
My best present that I ever game him was a collage of all the things he wasn't getting for fathers day that year. Just because he handed me a brochure from Maplins a few days before.